Looking for Elevator Murder Cases! (Found)

24.09.2022: one new entry.

Among all the types of locked room murders and other impossible crimes, a good old elevator murder has a special place for me. However, it doesn’t seem to be that popular. These are the deductive stories about elevators I currently know:

  • Alan Thomas’ The Death of Laurence Vining (1928) – decribed by Adey as “Death by stabbing in a locked lift”. Via TomCat and Velleic.
  • George Goodchild’s “McLean of Scotland Yard, Chapter XII” (1929) – described by Adey as “Death by shooting in a closed lift”.
  • Roger Scarlett’s Murder Among the Angells (1932) – an old man is stabbed while moving in a cloed elevator, despite the size of his wheelchair not even leaving place for another person. Via TomCat and Velleic.
  • Stanislas-André Steeman’s Six Dead Men (1932) – described by Adey as “Death by stabbing in a closed elevator”.
  • The Carr & Rhode co-authored novel, Fatal Descent (1939) – described by Adey as “Death by shooting in a closed elevator”.
  • Clayton Rawson’s “Claws of Satan” (Red Star Mystery – June 1940; as by “Stuart Towne”) – Don Diavolo vanishes from a locked elevator after being arrested. Via TomCat.
  • Cornell Woolrich’s “Finger of Doom” (Detective Fiction Weekly – 22 June 1940) – described by Skupin as “Disappearance of an innocent girl seen to enter a guarded apartment building after entering the elevator, with all tenants denying having seen her”.
  • James Yaffe’s “Department of Impossible Crimes” (EQMM – July 1943) – described by Adey as “Death by stabbing in a closed lift between floors and unoccupied but for the victim”.
  • Bill Krohn’s “The Impossible Murder of Dr. Satanus” (EQMM – April 1965) – described by Adey as “Death by stabbing in a locked lift”.
  • Josef Škvorecký’s ““A Tried and Proven Method”/”Dobrá stará daktyloskopie” (1966) – described by Adey as “Death by falling from a cable car that arrives at itsdestination empty”.
  • Edward D. Hoch’s “The Vanishing of Velma” (AHMM – August 1969) – described by Adey as “Disappearance of a girl from a Ferris wheel under observation”.
  • “The Two Million Clams of Cap’n Jack”, Banacek s01e08 (1973) – described by Skupin as “Disappearance of valuable stock certificate plates, and the guard who carried them, from an elevator”.
  • “The Adventure of the 12th Floor Express”, Ellery Queen s01e05 (1975) – newspaper publisher shot in a private elevator while being mid-floors.
  • “The Real Gone Gondola”, The Clue Club s01e03 (1976) – impossible disappearance from a closed moving ski lift under observation. Via TomCat.
  • William Marshall’s Skullduggery (1979) – described by Skupin as “The mugging of victims in an elevator when it stopped at a floor on which the outside door had been nailed shut”.
  • Peter Godfrey’s “The Flung-Back Lid” (John Creasey’s Crime Collection, 1979) – Death by stabbing in a closed cable car. Via TomCat.
  • Phillips Lore’s Murder Behind Closed Doors (1980) – Adey describes impossibility number 4 as “Attempted murder by poison inside a locked elevator”.
  • Reginald Hill’s “There Are No Ghosts in the Soviet Union” (volume of the same name, 1987) – described by Adey as “A man is pushed into a lift and promptly disappears through the floor”.
  • Edward D. Hoch’s “The Way Up to Hades” (AHMM – January 1988) – Described by Skupin as “Disappearance of a man seen to enter and to be travelling in a glass elevator that made no stops between floors”. I desperately forgot about it despite it being awesome and was reminded by TomCat and Velleic.
  • “Columbo Goes to the Guillotine”, Columbo s08e01 (1989) – problem 1 described by Skupin as “Death by guillotine in a warehouse apartment with door and horizontal bifold elevator door locked on the inside”.
  • Kate Wilhelm’s Smart House (1989) – disappointing solution, via TomCat.
  • “Morning: What Goes Up” (comic story), in The Maze Agency Special (1990) – death by shooting in a closed elevator, which victim rode with another innocent person. Via Dr. Nemo.
  • Christopher Golden’s “The Ultimate Locked Room” (The Ten-Minute Detective, 1997) – described by Skupin as “Death by a blow to the head in an elevator with no-one inside but the victim”.
  • Three Detective Conan episodes: The Desperate Revival (1999, ch. 251-60, eps. 188-93), Hattori Heiji vs. Kudō Shinichi: Deduction Battle on the Ski Slope! (2005, ch.518-22, ep. 490), Deduction Showdown at the Haunted Hotel (2011, ch. 768-70, eps. 646-7), Everyone Saw (2013, ch. 831-3, eps. 710-711).
  • Lois H. Gresh & Robert Weinberg’s “Death Rides the Elevator” in Mammoth Book of Locked-Room Mysteries and Impossible Crimes, 2000 – described by Skupin as “Decapitation of a man riding in an elevator on his own”.
  • Detective Conan original episode, The Entrance to the Maze: The Anger of the Colossus (ep. 208, 2000) by Hashiba Chiaki – impossible murder onboard a cable car with the body disappearing and reappearing elsewhere within seconds.
  • “Turnabout Goodbyes”/”逆転、そしてサヨナラ“, Phoenix Wright: Ace Attorney entry 4 (2001) – murder by shooting committed in an elevator,the suspect actually remembers inflicting the shot, but is innocent.
  • “Mr. Monk Goes to the Carnival”, Monk s01e05 (2002) – described by Skupin as “Death by stabbing of a man on a Ferris wheel which he rode with another innocent person”.
  • “Mr Monk Goes To Vegas”, Monk s03e14 (2005) – seemingly an accident in an elevator, the only suspect has ironclad alibi. Via Dr. Nemo.
  • Paul Halter’s “The Tunnel of Death” (translation in EQMM – March/April 2005) – described by Skupin as “Death by shooting in an enclosed moving escalator when the victim was guarded on all sides”. Via TomCat.
  • Siobhan Dowd’s The London Eye Mystery (2007) – described by Skupin as “Disappearance of a boy seen to get into one of the pods of the London Eye”.
  • Maria Hudgins’ “Murder on the London Eye” (EQMM – December 2007) – described by Skupin as “Death by strangling in a capsule on the London Eye when witnesses say the victim was alone”.
  • Mike Cooper’s “Whiz Bang” (EQMM – September/October 2011) – described by Skupin as “Death by shooting of a man on his own in a glass elevator between floors”. Via TomCat.
  • Gavin MacDonald’s “Death Lift” (self-published in The Forsyth Saga, 2011) – described by Skupin as “Death by stabbing of a man in a lift, when of the four other people in the building, all alibied each other for the time of the murder”.
  • “Last Woman Standing”, CSI s13e16 (2013) – described by Skupin as “Death by throat slitting in an elevator of a victim alone, with no murder weapon”.
  • “Enough Nemesis to Go Around”, Elementary s03e01 (2014) – described by Skupin as “Death by shooting in a locked elevator in a hotel”.
  • Alexander Prokopovich’s “Death in the Elevator”/”Смерть в лифте” (Убийство в закрытой комнате. Лучшие рассказы, 2014) – a man is found shot after after a non-stop ride in an elevator, but it is not a suicide. A Russian-language non-translated story with an apparently original solution, via Roger Sheringham.
  • Imamura Masahiro’s Death Among the Undead (2017; has a quasi-impossible murder in an elevator) – via TomCat.
  • Robert Innes’ Flatline (2018) – after spending twenty-five minute in a elevator stuck between stories, the victim turns out to be dead by drowning. Via TomCat.
  • “Who Killed the Guy on the Ski Lift?”, The Good Cop s01e07 (2018) – victim stabbed while being on the ski lift only accompanied by a person assumed innocent.
  • Tom Mead’s Death and the Conjuror (2022) – via Scott. I seriously need to go up-to-date.

Are there any else anywhere at all? Please add elevator murder (and non-murder) stories that you know to this list!

14 thoughts on “Looking for Elevator Murder Cases! (Found)

  1. Here’s you go:

    Alan Thomas’ The Death of Laurence Vining (1928)
    Roger Scarlett’s Murder Among the Angells (1932)
    Clayton Rawson’s “Claws of Satan” (Red Star Mystery, Jun. 1940; as by “Stuart Towne” and has Don Diavolo vanishing from a locked elevator after being arrested)
    Mike Cooper’s “Whizbang” (EQMM, Sept/Oct. 2011)
    Edward D. Hoch’s “The Way Up to Hades” (AHMM, Jan. 1988 and collected in Funeral in the Fog, 2021)
    Masahiro Imamura’s Death Among the Undead (2017; has a quasi-impossible murder in an elevator)
    Robert Innes’ Flatline (2018)

    Like

  2. Check out Noel Calef’s novel Ascenseur pour L:Echafaud (Elevator to the Gallows) and published in English as Frantic — as well as made into a noir film by Louis Malle — excellent film!!

    Like

    1. But is it an impossible crime? From all plot descriptions I can find, nothing impossible happens there connected with the elevator specifically!

      Like

  3. Do you have Robert Adey’s “Locked Room Murders”? That lists a few more. One of the Roger Scarlett books apparently has one. And The Death of Laurence Vining has one, mentioned in reviews.
    One I have read is “The Way Up To Hades”, by Edward Hoch.
    That’s not all that are listed but those are the main ones. Funnily enough it doesn’t include everything in your list.

    Like

  4. Tom Mead’s recently published lover letter to the Golden Age, Death and the Conjuror, has a meticulously executed murder in an elevator.

    Like

  5. Kate Wilhelm’s Smart House (1989) can also be added to the list, but let the reader be warned, the concept is better than the execution.

    What about impossible crimes aboard cable cars (Peter Godfrey’s “The Flung-Back Lid,” 1979) and escalators (Paul Halter’s “The Tunnel of Death,” 2000)? In principle, they pose a similar, if not identical, problem as a locked elevator with the main difference being the direction in which the crime scene travels. Surprisingly, the Scooby Doo knock-off cartoon, Clue Club, has an excellent take on the impossible disappearance from a closed, moving and watched ski-lift gondola (The Real Gone Gondola, 1976). Case Closed vol. 50 and 51 has a story in which someone’s shot while riding a ski-lift.

    Like

    1. I already added a ski lift story (exactly that one from Detective Conan). I am kinda sure there was another similar one among the early AOs of Conan, but cannot find it at the moment…

      I would prefer the car murders not qualify, as they are a somewhat different entity. However, the murders on self-moving cabins which are following single tracks and mostly uncontrolled by participants should, I think, be listed: such as ski lifts, cable cars, tunnel cable cars. It really, really seems that crimes on ferris wheels should be in the same category, as there is no real difference with, say, the case of “The Way Up to Hades”.

      Also, while writing this, I realized the Conan case I remembered was Episode 208, “The Entrance to the Maze: The Anger of the Colossus”, and I will definitely include it!

      Like

      1. Item 1659 is John Rowland’s Calamity in Kent (1950; “death by stabbing in a locked cliff-railway cabin”). However, it’s only a very minor, disappointing part of the plot and the cliff-railway cabin was not moving when the body was discovered. It appeared there overnight and was discovered the following morning by the operator.

        I know of two impossible crime stories featuring a ferris wheel, Siobhan Dowd’s The London Eye Mystery (2007) and Maria Hudgins’ “Murder on the London Eye” (2007), but no idea whether they good or not. The first story from Case Closed/Detective Conan concerns a murder on a roller coaster ride.

        Liked by 1 person

    2. Okay, so not including Rowland!

      Both London Eye stories already included (Dowd’s one caused not a small amount of sound in Japanese mystery writing circles when it was recently released in Japanese, so that seems to be a sign of quality), also the Hoch story “The Vanishing of Velma” is also included. Somehow it doesn’t feel right to include that Conan story though, as the ride is, strictly saying, not hermetic.

      Like

  6. I have read the Reginald Hill. I recommend it as a story, but I don’t really consider it a locked room mystery; the setup is there but the story doesn’t focus on it and if I’d read it just for that I would have been disappointed.

    Like

  7. Ichi Orihara’s short story The Case of the Disappearance of the Face of the Earth/The Locked Room In the Air features a person disappearing from a rope-way cabin: https://ho-lingnojikenbo.blogspot.com/search/label/Orihara%20Ichi%20%7C%20%E6%8A%98%E5%8E%9F%E4%B8%80
    I found it while leafing through Alice Arisugawa’s Illustrated Guide to Locked Rooms.

    In The Sekimeiya: Spun Glass, an elevator plays a very important role in establishing suspects’ movements and alibis, and one murder happens inside the elevator while it’s stopped between floors (though I’m not sure if I would consider it an impossible crime).

    Like

  8. There’s another one in the Ace Attorney manga—Turnabout Power vs. Supernatural Power, in which the victim disappears from an elevator between floors.

    Also the book I’m revising right now involves an elevator crime, so maybe at some point that will show up on the list

    Like

  9. The first novel in J.L. Blackhurst’s “The Impossible Crimes Series,” <I>Three Card Murder</I> (2023), features three locked room murders with the second murder concerning a stabbing inside an elevator. The trick is a fairly minor and is given the least attention of the three, but still qualifies for this list.

    Like

Leave a comment